Effectiveness of Pretrial in Testing the Legality of Arrest and Detention
Article Sidebar
-
Human Rights, Judicial Review, Legality of Detention
Abstract
Background: Pretrial procedures play a vital role in testing the legality of arrest and detention, ensuring that individuals' rights are protected against arbitrary detentions. Legal safeguards such as judicial review of arrests are essential in preventing abuses of power by law enforcement agencies. In many jurisdictions, pretrial hearings serve as a critical mechanism to determine whether there is enough evidence to justify continued detention, thus promoting the rule of law and human rights protection. However, the effectiveness of pretrial procedures in safeguarding individuals from unlawful detention remains a topic of debate.
Objective: This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of pretrial hearings in testing the legality of arrest and detention. The research investigates how these procedures influence the protection of individual rights and the overall functioning of the justice system.
Method: A qualitative research design was employed, utilizing case studies, legal analysis, and interviews with legal professionals, detainees, and human rights advocates. Data were collected from multiple jurisdictions to assess the impact of pretrial procedures on the legality of detention.
Results: The findings suggest that pretrial hearings are an effective mechanism for testing the legality of arrests and detentions, but their application is inconsistent, with some jurisdictions lacking adequate legal frameworks to ensure timely and fair reviews.
Conclusion: The study concludes that while pretrial hearings can significantly contribute to the protection of individual rights, improvements in procedural consistency and access to legal representation are needed to enhance their effectiveness.
Full text article
References
Abbas, L., de Brito Caruso, G., dos Santos, B. M. C., & Fabris, L. (2024). Prison and maternity in the Legal Framework on Early Childhood: Effects of a precedent in the substitution of pretrial detention into home detention. Revista Brasileira de Politicas Publicas, 14(3), 98–131. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.5102/rbpp.v14i3.8601
Ansanelli, V. (2024). The American Exceptionalism in the Transformation of Pretrial. Politica del Diritto, 55(2), 291–312. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1437/113969
Bienenstock, S., & Kopp, P. (2023). The extensive reach of the FCPA beyond American borders: Is a bad deal always better than a good trial? Public Choice, 196(3–4), 381–401. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11127-023-01056-x
Billi, M., Dal Pont, T. R., Sabo, I. C., Lagioia, F., Sartor, G., & Rover, A. J. (2023). Supervised Learning, Explanation and Interpretation from Pretrial Detention Decisions by Italian and Brazilian Supreme Courts. Dalam Sales T.P., Guizzardi G., Araújo J., & Borbinha J. (Ed.), Lect. Notes Comput. Sci.: Vol. 14319 LNCS (hlm. 131–140). Springer Science and Business Media Deutschland GmbH; Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-47112-4_12
Bouchard, K., Lalande, K., Coutinho, T., Mulvagh, S., Pacheco, C., Liu, S., Saw, J., So, D., Reed, J. L., Chiarelli, A., Stragapede, E., Robert, H., Lappa, N., Sun, L., Wells, G., & Tulloch, H. (2023). Spontaneous Coronary Artery Dissection Across the Health Care Pathway: A National, Multicenter, Patient-Informed Investigation. Journal of the American Heart Association, 12(24). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.123.032141
Choi, K.-S., & Lee, C. S. (2023). In the Name of Dark Web Justice: A Crime Script Analysis of Hacking Services and the Underground Justice System. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 39(2), 201–221. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/10439862231157520
Cooper, K. G., Bhattacharya, S., Daniels, J. P., Cheed, V., Gennard, L., Leighton, L., Pirie, D., Melyda, M., Monahan, M., Weckesser, A., Roberts, T., Denny, E., Ocansey, L., Stubbs, C., Cox, E., Jones, G., Justin Clark, T., Saridogan, E., Gupta, J. K., … Middleton, L. J. (2024). Preventing recurrence of endometriosis-related pain by means of long-acting progestogen therapy: The PRE-EMPT RCT. Health Technology Assessment, 28(55). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.3310/SQWY6998
Dawansa, R., & Iriyanto, E. (2023). Penghentian Penuntutan Berdasarkan Keadilan Restoratif. Jurnal Hukum Unissula, 39(1), 12–30. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.26532/jh.v39i1.26675
de Paula, L. C., & de Barros, V. D. M. (2023). The fallacy of isonomy between the parties in the brazilian criminal procedure: When the material and budgetary structure matters! Cadernos de Dereito Actual, 2023(20), 134–156. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7919239
Demura, M. (2024). HOW THE LAW PROTECTS INDIVIDUALS FROM DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN POLAND AND UKRAINE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY. International Comparative Jurisprudence, 10(2), 282–294. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.13165/j.icj.2024.12.008
García-González, D. L., Casadei, E., Aparicio-Ruiz, R., Ortiz Romero, C., Valli, E., Brereton, P., Koidis, A., Korytkowska, M., Servili, M., Selvaggini, R., Lacoste, F., Escobessa, J., Vichi, S., Quintanilla-Casas, B., Tres, A., Golay, P.-A., Lucci, P., Moret, E., Bendini, A., & Gallina Toschi, T. (2024). Multianalyte analysis of volatile compounds in virgin olive oils using SPME-GC with FID or MS detection: Results of an international interlaboratory validation. European Journal of Lipid Science and Technology, 126(12). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejlt.202300079
Hedberg, J., Sundbom, M., Edholm, D., Aahlin, E. K., Szabo, E., Lindberg, F., Johnsen, G., Førland, D. T., Johansson, J., Kauppila, J. H., Svendsen, L. B., Nilsson, M., Lindblad, M., Lagergren, P., Larsen, M. H., Åkesson, O., Löfdahl, P., Mala, T., & Achiam, M. P. (2024). Randomized controlled trial of nasogastric tube use after esophagectomy: Study protocol for the kinetic trial. Diseases of the Esophagus, 37(6). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1093/dote/doae010
Ivanov, D., Alimamedov, E., Yakovleva, V., Lapin, V., & Barchukov, V. (2024). THE ROLE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF SEARCH AS A MEANS OF FORCIBLE SEIZURE OF PROPERTY IN ORDER TO COMPENSATE FOR DAMAGE CAUSED BY A CRIME. Relacoes Internacionais No Mundo Atual, 1(43), 377–385. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.21902/Revrima.v1i43.6728
Kaji, R., Izumi, Y., & Oki, R. (2024). Ultra-high dose methylcobalamin and other emerging therapies for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Current Opinion in Neurology, 37(5), 593–602. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1097/WCO.0000000000001311
Kopak, A. M., & Singer, A. J. (2023). Substance Use Disorder, Bail Reform, and Failure to Appear in Court: Results From a Naturalistic Study. Journal of Drug Issues, 53(2), 183–195. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/00220426221107561
Loinaz, I. (2025). Misconceptions about intimate partner violence risk assessment algorithm in the Basque Country: A reply to Valdivia, Hyde-Vaamonde, and García-Marcos (2024). AI and Society. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-025-02192-2
Lönnqvist, E. (2024). The politics of pretrial detention: Mapping the development of Swedish remand policy. Punishment and Society. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/14624745241296537
López Castillo, A. C., Usaqui Barbaran, E., López Orellana, M. O., Campos Barreto, A., Soria Ramirez, L., Ortega Chávez, W., López Panaifo, V. T., & Astohuaman Huaranga, A. D. (2024). Media Pressure and Pretrial Detention Requirements in Ucayali, Peru: A Study Based on Neutrosophic Measures. Neutrosophic Sets and Systems, 74, 538–548. Scopus.
McKinnon, I., Moore, J., Lyall, A., & Forrester, A. (2023). Screening for mental disorders in police custody settings. BJPsych Advances, 29(6), 407–416. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1192/bja.2022.25
Nelson, C. (2024). The ‘most maligned’ witness in the Christopher Dawson case: Gender, power, media and legal culture in the digitally distributed live-streamed court. Crime, Media, Culture, 20(1), 83–106. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/17416590231168330
Pretrial, Trial, and Appeal Procedures. (2024). Dalam Legal Medicine: Health Care Law and Medical Ethics, Eighth Edition (hlm. 395–403). Elsevier; Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-443-12128-9.00057-7
Quintana-Navarrete, M., & Fondevila, G. (2025a). Public defenders versus private attorneys: A comparison of criminal case disposition outcomes by type of counsel in Mexico. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 25(2), 393–420. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/17488958221116999
Quintana-Navarrete, M., & Fondevila, G. (2025b). Public defenders versus private attorneys: A comparison of criminal case disposition outcomes by type of counsel in Mexico. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 25(2), 393–420. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1177/17488958221116999
Senftleber, N. (2024). NO MORE NIXON: A PROPOSED CHANGE TO RULE 17(C) OF THE FEDERAL RULES OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE. Fordham Law Review, 92(4), 1697–1739. Scopus.
Suastuti, E., Haq, L. M. H., Harimurti, Y. W., & Yuherawana, D. S. B. (2024). TRANSFORMATION AND EFFECTS OF HUMAN RIGHTS PROTECTION ON DETERMINING CORRUPTION SUSPECTS AS A PRETRIAL OBJECT UNDER THE INDONESIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM. Lex Scientia Law Review, 8(2), 817–858. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.15294/lslr.v8i2.14667
Sumardiana, B., Pujiyono, P., & Cahyaningtyas, I. (2024). Reforming Justice: Unpacking the Prejudication and Post-Judicate Dynamics of the Sarpin Case in Law and Practice in Indonesia. Lex Scientia Law Review, 8(2), 1089–1116. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.15294/lslr.v8i2.10744
Susilo, E., Din, M., & Mansur, T. M. (2024). Justice Delayed, Justice Denied: A Critical Examination of Repeated Suspect Status in Indonesia. Hasanuddin Law Review, 10(3), 342–357. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.20956/halrev.v10i3.6088
Thompson, P. A., Moody, G., Coulman, E., Owen-Jones, E., Patel, F., Gray, K. M., Hastings, R. P., Longman, A., Lugg-Widger, F., Segrott, J., Badger, J., Flynn, S., Langdon, P. E., & Playle, R. (2024). Statistical analysis plan for the SOLUTIONS randomised controlled trial with internal pilot: Solution Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT) in 10–17-year-olds presenting at policy custody. Trials, 25(1). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-024-08457-3
Traore, D., Ramde, N. W., Kabre, S., & Doudoulgou, B. (2024). Medical examination for police custody: Analysis of the case of the Ouagadougou House of Arrest and Correction (MACO) in Burkina Faso. Archives of Legal Medicine, 15(4). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aolm.2024.200501
Van Der Spoel, E., Van Vliet, N. A., Poortvliet, R. K. E., Du Puy, R. S., Den Elzen, W. P. J., Quinn, T. J., Stott, D. J., Sattar, N., Kearney, P. M., Blum, M. R., Alwan, H., Rodondi, N., Collet, T.-H., Westendorp, R. G. J., Ballieux, B. E., Jukema, J. W., Dekkers, O. M., Gussekloo, J., Mooijaart, S. P., & Van Heemst, D. (2024). Incidence and Determinants of Spontaneous Normalization of Subclinical Hypothyroidism in Older Adults. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 109(3), e1167–e1174. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1210/clinem/dgad623
Vyhivskyi, I., & Trembetsk, A. (2024). NATIONAL POLICE OF UKRAINE ACTIVITIES UNDER THE CONDITIONS OF THE RUSSO-UKRAINIAN WAR (2014 – 2024): ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGES, SECURITY CHALLENGES AND TASKS. East European Historical Bulletin, 2024(32), 148–157. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.24919/2519-058X.32.311509
Walker, J. T., & Hemmens, C. (2023). Legal Guide for Police: Constitutional Issues, Twelfth Edition. Dalam Legal Guide for Police: Constitutional Issues, Twelfth Edition (hlm. 278). Taylor and Francis; Scopus. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003341109
Yunin, O., Dal, A., Polovnikov, V., Shumska, N., & Koteliukh, M. (2024). The Administrative-legal and Criminal Aspect of Prosecuting Persons for Offenses in the Field of Illegal Drug Trafficking. Journal of Drug and Alcohol Research, 13(9). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.4303/JDAR/236407
Zabatiero, J., Stone, L., McCormack, D., Zarb, D., Nolan, A., Highfield, K., Skouteris, H., Edwards, S., & Straker, L. (2024). “I Use Technologies Strategically With My Family Now”: Practices That Parents Value to Promote Physical Activity in Young Children. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 21(11), 1121–1131. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2024-0317
Zainal, N. H., Tan, H. H., Hong, R. Y. S., & Newman, M. G. (2024). Testing the Efficacy of a Brief, Self-Guided Mindfulness Ecological Momentary Intervention on Emotion Regulation and Self-Compassion in Social Anxiety Disorder: Randomized Controlled Trial. JMIR Mental Health, 11(1). Scopus. https://doi.org/10.2196/53712
Zottola, S. A., Stewart, K., Cloud, V., Hassett, L., & Desmarais, S. L. (2024). Predictive Bias in Pretrial Risk Assessment: Application of the Public Safety Assessment in a Native American Population. Law and Human Behavior, 48(5–6), 398–414. Scopus. https://doi.org/10.1037/lhb0000562
Authors
Copyright (c) 2025 Sofia Lim, Rachel Chan, Ava Lee
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
